Choosing the right AI music generator can be the difference between a video that feels professional and one that feels like a generic stock slideshow. For content creators, two names frequently top the list: Ecrett Music and Loudly. While both leverage artificial intelligence to bypass the headache of copyright strikes, they cater to very different creative workflows.
Quick Comparison Table
| Feature | Ecrett Music | Loudly |
|---|---|---|
| Best For | Budget-conscious video creators & YouTubers | Professional creators & social media influencers |
| Generation Method | Scene, Mood, and Genre selection | Text-to-Music, Genre-based, and Templates |
| Customization | Instrument toggling & structure blocks | Full AI Studio, Stem Splitter, & SFX generator |
| Licensing | Royalty-free for video/games/podcasts | Royalty-free with direct platform distribution |
| Starting Price | $4.99/month (billed annually) | $8.00/month (billed annually) |
Overview of Ecrett Music
Ecrett Music is a streamlined AI tool designed specifically for content creators who need high-quality background music without a steep learning curve. Owned by the team behind Soundraw, Ecrett focuses on simplicity: users select a scene (like "Travel" or "Cooking"), a mood, and a genre to generate a track instantly. It offers a massive library of over 50 million combinations, ensuring that your background score feels unique even if you use the same settings multiple times. Its primary goal is to provide a "set it and forget it" solution for YouTubers, podcasters, and indie game developers who want to avoid copyright issues at an affordable price point.
Overview of Loudly
Loudly is a more robust, multi-faceted platform that combines AI music generation with professional-grade editing and distribution tools. Unlike simpler generators, Loudly offers a "Text-to-Music" engine that allows creators to describe their vision in plain English to get a tailored track. Beyond generation, Loudly functions as a social and collaborative ecosystem where users can remix tracks, split stems (isolating vocals or drums), and even distribute their music directly to streaming platforms like Spotify and Apple Music. It is built for the modern digital creator who wants to play a more active role in the "production" of their audio rather than just picking a background loop.
Detailed Feature Comparison
The core difference between these two tools lies in the depth of customization. Ecrett Music provides a "block-based" customization system where you can toggle instruments like melody, backing, bass, and drums on or off for different sections of the song. While effective for simple video timing, it doesn't allow for granular sound design. Loudly, on the other hand, features a comprehensive AI Studio. In this environment, you can use a "Stem Splitter" to deconstruct audio files into individual components, allowing you to isolate or remove specific elements like a vocal track or a drum line for a custom remix.
When it comes to generation methods, Loudly feels more modern. Its Text-to-Music feature allows for descriptive prompts (e.g., "lo-fi hip hop with a melancholic piano and rainy atmosphere"), whereas Ecrett relies on a fixed menu of categories. While Ecrett’s menu is extensive and easy to navigate, it can feel restrictive for creators with a very specific, niche vision. Loudly also includes an AI Sample Generator and SFX generator, making it a better "all-in-one" audio suite for complex video projects that require more than just a background song.
Licensing and distribution are another major point of divergence. Ecrett Music follows a traditional royalty-free model: you pay your subscription, and you can use the music in your videos, games, or podcasts forever. Loudly operates more like a music label partner; while the music is royalty-free, they encourage (and sometimes require for certain monetization tiers) that you distribute the tracks through their own platform. This is a huge benefit for creators who want to build a brand on Spotify, but it can be an extra layer of complexity for someone who just wants a simple file to drop into Premiere Pro.
Pricing Comparison
- Ecrett Music:
- Free: Preview tracks and save favorites (no downloads).
- Individual ($4.99/mo billed annually): Unlimited downloads, YouTube monetization, and commercial use for individuals.
- Business ($14.99/mo billed annually): Everything in Individual, but the license applies to a full company or agency.
- Loudly:
- Free: 1 download per day, 0.5-minute previews, personal use only.
- Personal (~$8.00/mo billed annually): 300 downloads, full song lengths (up to 7 mins), and social media monetization.
- Pro (~$24.00/mo billed annually): 500 downloads, high-quality WAV files, and professional commercial rights.
Use Case Recommendations
Use Ecrett Music if...
- You are a YouTuber or podcaster on a tight budget.
- You want to generate a track in under 30 seconds with zero musical knowledge.
- You need simple background music that won't distract from your voiceover.
Use Loudly if...
- You want to use AI to create music you can actually release on streaming platforms.
- You need advanced features like stem splitting or text-to-music prompts.
- You are a social media influencer (TikTok/Instagram) looking for unique, trend-worthy sounds and SFX.
Verdict
If your goal is efficiency and value, Ecrett Music is the winner. It is significantly cheaper and offers a straightforward "select and create" workflow that is perfect for the average video creator who doesn't want to spend hours tweaking audio stems.
However, if you are a power user or a digital artist, Loudly is the superior choice. Its ability to generate music from text prompts, split stems for remixing, and distribute tracks to major streaming services makes it a much more powerful creative partner, even if it comes with a higher price tag and a slightly steeper learning curve.